Forbes Advisor’s analysis found Nationwide to be the best car insurance company overall, with Erie, Travelers and USAA excelling in certain areas. We analyzed insurers nationwide to identify the best car insurance companies based on costs, coverage options, claims processes and complaints.
Here are Forbes Advisor’s expert picks for the best car insurance of January 2024:
- Nationwide Insurance: Best Overall
- Erie Insurance: Best for Collision Repairs
- Travelers Insurance: Great for Drivers With a Speeding Ticket
- USAA Insurance: Best for Military Members and Veterans
- Progressive Insurance: Best for Drivers With a DUI
- Auto-Owners Insurance: Best for New Cars
- Geico Insurance: Great for Drivers With Poor Credit
- Westfield Insurance: Best for Family Discounts
